Important insight offered in Berman et al. (2010) and Selden (2009):
As a government employee for the past 13 years, I recognize the need to incorporate and improve human capital management in government organizations. Selden defines human capital management in her book titled Human Capital: Tools and Strategies for the Public Sector as an essential component of any public management system. Human capital management refers to the systems, policies, procedures, and practices of managing human capital within public organizations, whether merit or non-merit systems, civil or non-civil service (Selden, 2009). For purposes of this blog, I will concentrate on the recruitment aspect of government employees. Currently government recruitment is not up to par with the private sector. Government recruitment is very structured and old fashioned. Selden encourages public organizations to improve and engage in strategic management by implementing performance metrics that will enable them to monitor identify, and diagnose human capital opportunities and challenges. The recruiting and hiring process in government organizations can be both lengthy and stressful.
My personal recruitment experience in the public sector has not been strategic and prompt. I recently transferred to the Miami office at the Florida Department of Transportation, District Six from Tampa, Florida. Although I am considered a veteran at the Department I underwent an extremely lengthy and frustrating recruitment process. It took District Six approximately 3 months before I was called in for an interview. The interview process at the Department is very cut and dry. For instance, there is a series of questions (usually 7-13 questions). The interview panel typically consists of four supervisors/managers and they each take turns at asking the same questions to all interviewees. An opportunity is given at the end of the interview to expand on your expertise or to state anything that will assist you in selling yourself. After attending the interview, I waited 4 months before I received the Department’s offer letter. I believe the recruitment process takes too long and sometimes causes the Department to miss out on essential candidates. I have seen many instances where vital candidates are selected for a position yet; the waiting process is so long that they decided to work elsewhere.
The corporation of advanced computer systems is in demand for government organizations. In Florida, currently the hiring source being utilized is “People First” where individuals are able to search for jobs per location, organization, title, etc. A great feature within the People First system is that individuals have the ability to maintain a master application in file within the program. However, it takes a very long time (approximately 3-4 months) before an applicant is contacted to attend an interview from the time of their application submission. The application is reviewed by staff members to assure all knowledge, skills, and abilities are met. The chain of inspection proceeds to many supervisors and managers before an applicant is ever contacted, hence, the need to make improvement to the selection process.
How can the recruiting method be improved?
Replacing the hiring system with a more effective and less time consuming process will be beneficial to public organizations. Times are changing and people are depending on the internet including social media for recruitment. The use of Facebook for job seekers has recently surfaced, broadening the social media attraction even more (see video below).
Berman et al. discuss recruitment strategies in their book Human Resource Management in Public Service. The encouragement of qualified candidates to apply is addressed in the following stages:
1. Planning and approval of the position
2. Preparation of the position announcement
3. Selection and use of specific strategies
Public organizations have come a long way in the recruitment process. Current trends have facilitated some of the proceduralism involved within the hiring process; however, there is still need for improvement. In Berman, the authors mention three initiatives the government has actively considered reforming:
1. Decentralization of staff activities
2. Simplify and invigorate intake functions
3. New staffing strategies (ex. on the spot hiring, fully online applications, and electronic applications)
Source: Berman et al, 2010, Selden, 2009